Cummings
Guides Home..|..Contact
This Site
.
.
Study
Guide Prepared by Michael J. Cummings...©
2010
.
Type
of Work
.......“Porphyria's
Lover” is a dramatic monologue, a poem that presents a moment in which
the speaker (narrator) discusses a topic and, in so doing, reveals his
feelings and state of mind to a listener or the reader. Only the narrator
talks—hence the term monologue, meaning single (mono) discourse
(logue). The main focus of a dramatic monologue is the personal
information about the speaker, not his topic. A dramatic monologue is a
type of character study.
Publication
Information
.......“Porphyria's
Lover” first appeared with the title "Porphyria" in the January issue of
The
Monthly Repository for 1836, published in London by Charles Fox. In
the same city, Ward, Lock & Company, Ltd., republished the poem in
1842 in Bells and Pomegranates, a collection of Browning' poems.
In the 1842 volume, the work appeared as one of two poems sharing the title
“Madhouse Cells.” In 1863, Browning changed the title of the poem to “Porphyria's
Lover.”
Setting
.......The
action in the poem takes place on a stormy evening in a cottage at an unidentified
locale. The time is the 1830s.
Characters
The Speaker/Narrator:
A man who welcomes his beloved's show of affection for him but kills her
a moment later.
Porphyria: The narrator's
beloved.
Summary
.......Rain
falls and high winds blow while the speaker (narrator) of the poem sits
in a room in his cottage, depressed. In walks Porphyria, quickly shutting
the door on the storm. After stoking the fire and warming the room, she
removes her wet cloak, shawl, gloves, and hat. Then she sits next to the
speaker and addresses him. When he does not reply, she places his arm around
her waist and draws his head to her shoulder. Her yellow hair falls over
his face.
.......She
tells him that she loves him. In the past, she has been reluctant to free
her passion from her pride “and give herself to me forever,” the speaker
says. But this night, the speaker says, she realizes that he is "pale /
For love for her” (lines 28-29) and decides to brave the storm to visit
him and tell him that she loves him. Her expression of her feelings for
him makes "my heart swell" (line 34), he says. His elation grows as he
considers how to respond to her.
.......“That
moment she was mine, mine, fair, / Perfectly pure and good. . . " (lines
36-37), he says.
.......So
here is what he does. He takes a string of her hair, winds it around her
throat three times, and strangles her. She did not suffer, he says. Of
that he is sure. When he unwinds the hair, color returns to her cheeks
as he kisses her. He props her up and puts her head on his shoulder.
.......And
now, he thinks, her will is done, and “she guessed not how / Her darling
one wish would be heard” (lines 56-57).
.......Then
they sit there all through the night. All the while, he feels no guilt
for killing her, noting, “And yet God has not said a word.” The reader
is left with the impression that the narrator is a psychopath.
Text
.........Porphyria's
Lover
.........By
Robert Browning
1.......The
rain set early in to-night,
2.......The
sullen wind was soon awake,
3.......It
tore the elm-tops down for spite,
4.......And
did its worst to vex the lake:1
5.......I
listened with heart fit to break.
6.......When
glided in Porphyria; straight
7.......She
shut the cold out and the storm,
8.......And
kneeled and made the cheerless grate
9.......Blaze
up, and all the cottage warm;
10.....Which
done, she rose, and from her form
11.....Withdrew
the dripping cloak and shawl,
12.....And
laid her soiled gloves by, untied
13.....Her
hat and let the damp hair fall,
14.....And,
last, she sat down by my side
15.....And
called me. When no voice replied,
16.....She
put my arm about her waist,
17.....And
made her smooth white shoulder bare
18.....And
all her yellow hair displaced,
19.....And,
stooping, made my cheek lie there,
20.....And
spread, o'er all, her yellow hair,
21.....Murmuring
how she loved me—she
22.....Too
weak, for all her heart's endeavor,
23.....To
set its struggling passion free
24.....From
pride, and vainer ties dissever,
25.....And
give herself to me forever.
26.....But
passion sometimes would prevail,
27.....Nor
could to-night's gay feast2
restrain
28.....A
sudden thought of one so pale
29.....For
love of her, and all in vain:
30.....So,
she was come through wind and rain.
31.....Be
sure I looked up at her eyes
32.....Happy
and proud; at last I knew
33.....Porphyria
worshiped me; surprise
34.....Made
my heart swell, and still it grew
35.....While
I debated what to do.
36.....That
moment she was mine, mine, fair,
37.....Perfectly
pure and good: I found
38.....A
thing to do, and all her hair
39.....In
one long yellow string I wound
40.....Three
times her little throat around,
41.....And
strangled her. No pain felt she;3
42.....I
am quite sure she felt no pain.
43.....As
a shut bud that holds a bee,4
44.....I
warily oped her lids: again
45.....Laughed
the blue eyes without a stain.
46.....And
I untightened next the tress
47.....About
her neck; her cheek once more
48.....Blushed
bright beneath my burning kiss:
49.....I
propped her head up as before,
50.....Only,
this time by shoulder bore
51.....Her
head, which droops upon it still:
52.....The
smiling rosy little head,
53.....So
glad it has its utmost will,
54.....That
all it scorned at once is fled,
55.....And
I, its love, am gained instead!
56.....Porphyria's
love: she guessed not how
57.....Her
darling one wish would be heard.
58.....And
thus we sit together now,
59.....And
all night long we have not stirred,
60.....And
yet God has not said a word!
.
.
Notes
1....Lines
1-4: The narrator seems to project his feelings onto nature.
2....gay
feast: Porphyria may have been attending a social event. Then, thinking
of the narrator, she left it and came to him.
3....no.
. .she: The narrator has convinced himself that Porphyria did not suffer.
4....As
. . . bee: A dangling modifier that mars the poem. This clause attempts
to modify the pronoun I
at the beginning of line 44, turning the narrator into the "shut bud that
holds the bee."
Interpretation
and Themes
.......After
leading his readers to believe that "Porphyria's Lover" is a poem about
a typical romantic encounter, Browning shocks them with an unexpected event:
The narrator's calm and dispassionate strangulation of Porphyria.
.......Apparently,
the narrator's deep mental distress—referred to in line 5—causes him to
cross the border from sanity to insanity. (Or perhaps he was always mad
but retained enough control to mask his derangement.) Believing that Porphyria's
show of affection for him indicates that she wishes to “give herself to
me forever” (line 25), he makes it easy for her to remain at his side.
He simply kills her. Then he props her head on his shoulder and sits with
her all through the night. They become a tableau vivant.
.......Two
themes emerge from the poem. The first is this: Some people really can
be "madly in love." It is not at all uncommon for a person in love to exhibit
bizarre behavior, sometimes out of fear of losing the beloved; a man or
woman may even resort to violence against the beloved to prevent such a
loss. In "Porphyria's Lover," the narrator is madly in love not only figuratively
but also literally; he is psychopath. The second theme is this: Shocking,
unexpected behavior is part of life. Not infrequently, seemingly normal
and harmless people turn out to be child molesters, rapists, serial killers,
and so on.
Meaning
of Porphyria
.......You
may have noticed that dictionaries define porphyria as a group of
diseases characterized by sensitivity to sunlight as well as other symptoms,
such as skin blisters and anemia. This information might have led you to
conclude Porphyria had this disease and that the narrator murdered her
to end her suffering. But such a conclusion would be wrong. Here is why.
Browning wrote the poem in 1836. Porphyria was not identified and named
as a disease until 1874.
.......Browning
may have based the name Porphyria on the Greek word for purple,
porphyrus.
Since ancient times, purple has been associated with royalty, as attested
to by the purple robes worn by kings and queens. It may well be that the
narrator calls his beloved Porphyria to indicate that he considers her
a regal figure who has been out of his reach—until the stormy night when
she comes to him and confesses her love.
.
End Rhyme
.......The
rhyme scheme is ABABB (lines 1-5), BCBCC (lines 6-10), DEDEE (lines
11-15), and so on. In other words, in each set of five lines, the first
line rhymes with the third, and the second line rhymes with the fourth
and fifth.
.......All
but three of the end rhymes are masculine rather than feminine. Masculine
rhyme occurs when only the final syllable of a line rhymes with the final
syllable of another line, as in still
and will (lines 51 and 53) and
head,
fled, and instead
(lines 52, 54, 55). Feminine rhyme occurs when the final two syllables
of one line rhyme with the final two syllables of another line, as in endeavor,
dissever,
and forever
(lines 22, 24, 25). The dominance of masculine rhyme helps to underscore
the narrator's fatal conquest of Porphyria.
Internal
Rhyme
.......Browning
also also included occasional internal rhyme in the poem, as in the following
lines.
And kneeled and
made the cheerless grate
(line 8)
From pride,
and vainer ties dissever (line 21)
And I untightened next
the tress (line 46
Meter
.......The
meter in the poem consists mainly of iambic tetrameter, as the first four
lines of the poem demonstrate,
.......1...............2............3............4
The RAIN..|..set
EAR..|..ly
IN..|..to-
NIGHT,
.......1...............2.................3..................4
The SULL..|..en
WIND..|..was
SOON..|..a
WAKE,
......1...............2.................3..................4
It TORE..|..the
ELM-..|..tops
DOWN..|..for
SPITE,
......1.................2...............3...............4
And DID..|..its
WORST..|..to
VEX..|..the
LAKE
Structure
.......Although
the poem consists of one long stanza, it contains two distinct sections,
as follows.
Lines (1-30):
Browning presents what appears to be a traditional romantic love poem while
making Porphyria the active character and the narrator the passive.
Lines (31-60): Browning
turns the poem into a tale of horror while making the narrator the active
character and Porphyria the passive.
Enjambment
.......In
his poetry, Browning occasionally uses enjambment, a literary device in
which the sense of one line of verse is carried over to the next line without
a pause. Here is an example:
When glided in Porphyria;
straight
She shut the cold out and
the storm (lines 6-7)
Notice that straight
belongs with the words that follow it, not with the words that precede
it. Consequently, no pause occurs after it. Here are other examples of
enjambment.
And laid her soiled
gloves by, untied
Her hat and let the damp
hair fall (lines 12-13)
Porphyria worshiped me; surprise
Made my heart swell, and
still it grew (lines 33-34)
Anastrophe
.......From
time to time in "Porphyria's Lover," Browning uses anastrophe, the
inversion of the normal word order. A man forgotten
(instead of a forgotten man) is an example of anastrophe. Anastrophe
not only adds a poetic ring to verses but also helps the poet complete
his rhymes. Examples from the poem include the following:
When glided in Porphyria
(line 6)
(When Porphyria glided
in)
all her hair
In one long yellow string
I wound
Three times her little throat
around,
And strangled her. No pain
felt she (lines 38-41)
(I wound all her hair
in one yellow string three times around her little throat)
(She felt no pain)
Figures
of Speech
.......Following
are examples of figures of speech in the poem. (For definitions of figures
of speech, click here.)
Alliteration
The sullen
wind
was
soon
awake (line 2)
Murmuring
how she loved me (line 21)
Made
my
heart swell, and still
it grew (line 34)
I am quite sure
she
felt no pain (line 42)
Blushed
bright
beneath
my burning kiss (line 48)
Her
darling one wish
would
be heard (line 57)
Anaphora
And
thus we sit together now,
And
all night long we have not stirred,
And
yet God has not said a word! (lines 58-60)
Irony, Dramatic
The narrator's behavior
suggests that the speaker is insane. However, he himself apparently believes
he is normal.
Irony, Situational
After Porphyria
brings warmth to the cottage by stoking the fire
and offering the narrator
her love, the narrator coldly kills her.
The narrator is pale but
alive. Porphyria is rosy but dead.
Because Porphyria is "perfectly
pure and good," the
narrator kills her.
The narrator has committed
a monstrous deed. However, he
thinks he has made Porphyria
happy, believing she wanted to
die in order to be with
him forever. He says, "The smiling rosy
little head, / So glad it
has its utmost will."
Onomatopoeia
Murmuring (line
21)
Personification
The sullen wind
was soon awake,
It tore the elm-tops down
for spite (lines 2-3)
The wind exhibits human
emotions
Simile
As a shut bud that
holds a bee (line 43)
Comparison of Porphyria's
closed eye to a bud
Synecdoche
The smiling rosy
little head,
So glad it
has its utmost will (lines52-53)
The head stands for the
person
Study
Questions and Writing Topics
-
Do you agree that the narrator
is insane? If you do not, explain why you disagree?
-
Is the narrator describing the
incident as it happened? Or is he distorting information. Explain your
answer.
-
Write a dramatic monologue on
a subject of your choice.
-
Write an essay comparing and
contrasting the narrator of "Porphyria's Lover" with the narrator of "My
Last Duchess," another Browning poem.
.
|